CONTROL SYSTEMS SOCIETY
IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON AUTOMATIC CONTROL

REGULAR PAPER REVIEW FORM

Dear Reviewer:

Many of the fields in this review form are optional. The fields you MUST fill out are:
- Paper No. 00-000
- The Associate Editor's e-mail address in the "To:" field
- Your own e-mail address in the "Reviewer's E-Mail:" field
These are marked with a *.

Please also visit the TAC reviewer database to update or correct your data or to add your name to it.

Paper No.(00-000):* Reviewer No.:  Author(s):
Title:
Please return before: 
To:*

I. Overall Recommendation: (Please mark appropriate circles and boxes below)

ACCEPT
 
1.   Ready for publication, except for possible minor changes.
2.   Accept, subject to changes of a magnitude significant enough to require re-examination by the Associate Editor and perhaps by one or more reviewers. Please check if you wish to see the revision.

REJECT

3.   May contain publishable results. Requires complete rewriting, resubmission, and re-review of revised manuscript. If you feel that the eventual manuscript is likely to fall into the Paper or Technical Note category, indicate below.
4.
 
 
 		 Unlikely to contain publishable results because: 
Paper is so poorly written that contribution, if any, is obscure. 
Results are already known. They may be found in references listed in the review. 
Results are not correct, and there is no obvious way to correct them. 
Paper is not suitable for the IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control for reasons given below.

II . Category Assessment

Paper Technical Note
III. Confidential Comments to Editors (NOTE: These comments should be consistent with comments to authors.)

 

 Reviewer's Name : 
 and address: 

 Date: 
 Reviewer's E-Mail:* 
 (Required)    

IV . Comments to Authors

Type comments in the following text boxes. In addition, you may:

-Email your comments to the Associate Editor in a separate file.

or

-Upload one or more files with your review (see part V below).

a. Contribution of the paper (problem significance, importance of results, relevance for control engineering applications)

b. Technical correctness of the paper:

c. Quality of presentation (clarity, organization, motivation, introduction, conclusions, references):

d. Other comments:

V . Additional Comments

I want to upload additional file(s) with my review.

You will be directed to another page to upload file(s) after clicking "Send".

I will NOT provide additional files.
Click " Preview " if you want to check your report before e-mailing it.
Click " Send " when ready to e-mail it to the Associate Editor and possibly upload additional file(s).

NOTE: You MUST click "Send" to e-mail the review to the Associate Editor!

If you have any comments for this form, please contact
admin@control.bu.edu